1958 Brownlow Medal
[1957][1959][1958 Team Totals]
| Player | TM | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Neil Roberts | St Kilda | 24 |
| Brendan Edwards | Hawthorn | 22 |
| Bob Skilton | South Melbourne | 19 |
| Allen Aylett | North Melbourne | 17 |
| Bill Gunn | South Melbourne | 16 |
| John Birt | Essendon | 15 |
| Jack Clarke | Essendon | 15 |
| Jeff Gamble | Essendon | 15 |
| Harry Sullivan | Collingwood | 14 |
| Ted Whitten | Footscray | 14 |
| Owen Abrahams | Fitzroy | 13 |
| Ron Branton | Richmond | 13 |
| John Benetti | Carlton | 12 |
| Ray Gabelich | Collingwood | 12 |
| Neville Waller | Collingwood | 11 |
| Peter Falconer | Geelong | 11 |
| John Beckwith | Melbourne | 11 |
| Graham Donaldson | Carlton | 9 |
| Kevin Murray | Fitzroy | 9 |
| Noel Teasdale | North Melbourne | 9 |
| Paul Dodd | St Kilda | 9 |
| Alex Gardiner | Footscray | 8 |
| Geoff Williams | Geelong | 8 |
| Thorold Merrett | Collingwood | 7 |
| John Schultz | Footscray | 7 |
| Ian Aston | Fitzroy | 6 |
| Alan Gale | Fitzroy | 6 |
| Jim Gallagher | Footscray | 6 |
| John Haygarth | Geelong | 6 |
| Graham Arthur | Hawthorn | 6 |
| Allan Woodley | Hawthorn | 6 |
| Bob Johnson | Melbourne | 6 |
| Don Williams | Melbourne | 6 |
| Neil Doolan | North Melbourne | 6 |
| Laurie Dwyer | North Melbourne | 6 |
| Albert Mantello | North Melbourne | 6 |
| Peter Morris | Richmond | 6 |
| Ken Ward | Richmond | 6 |
| Bruce Comben | Carlton | 5 |
| John James | Carlton | 5 |
| Peter Lucas | Collingwood | 5 |
| Ken Turner | Collingwood | 5 |
| Alex Epis | Essendon | 5 |
| Alby Murdoch | Essendon | 5 |
| Don Furness | Fitzroy | 5 |
| Bob Henderson | Fitzroy | 5 |
| Ken Jones | Fitzroy | 5 |
| Bob Davis | Geelong | 5 |
| John ONeill | Geelong | 5 |
| Neil Trezise | Geelong | 5 |
| Ron Barassi | Melbourne | 5 |
| Brian Dixon | Melbourne | 5 |
| Ron Clegg | South Melbourne | 5 |
| Verdun Howell | St Kilda | 5 |
| Don Ross | Footscray | 4 |
| Colin Youren | Hawthorn | 4 |
| Fred Swift | Richmond | 4 |
| Eric Guy | St Kilda | 4 |
| Doug Beasy | Carlton | 3 |
| George Ferry | Carlton | 3 |
| John Heathcote | Carlton | 3 |
| Sergio Silvagni | Carlton | 3 |
| John Henderson | Collingwood | 3 |
| Frank Tuck | Collingwood | 3 |
| Murray Weideman | Collingwood | 3 |
| Mal Pascoe | Essendon | 3 |
| Graham Campbell | Fitzroy | 3 |
| Brian Pert | Fitzroy | 3 |
| Brian Buckley | Footscray | 3 |
| Ron Hovey | Geelong | 3 |
| Alf Hughes | Hawthorn | 3 |
| John Kennedy | Hawthorn | 3 |
| John Lord | Melbourne | 3 |
| Ian McLean | Melbourne | 3 |
| Laurie Mithen | Melbourne | 3 |
| Gerald Eastmure | North Melbourne | 3 |
| Fred Goldsmith | South Melbourne | 3 |
| John Heriot | South Melbourne | 3 |
| Marshall Younger | South Melbourne | 3 |
| Jim Guyatt | St Kilda | 3 |
| Alan Morrow | St Kilda | 3 |
| Bill Stephenson | St Kilda | 3 |
| Peter Barry | Carlton | 2 |
| Graham Gilchrist | Carlton | 2 |
| William Jones | Collingwood | 2 |
| Ron Reeves | Collingwood | 2 |
| Geoff Leek | Essendon | 2 |
| Graeme MacKenzie | Fitzroy | 2 |
| Lyall Anderson | Footscray | 2 |
| Herb Henderson | Footscray | 2 |
| Les Borrack | Geelong | 2 |
| Peter Campbell | Geelong | 2 |
| Neville Martin | Geelong | 2 |
| Colin Rice | Geelong | 2 |
| Ron Cabble | Hawthorn | 2 |
| John Dineen | Hawthorn | 2 |
| Ray McVilley | Hawthorn | 2 |
| Roy Simmonds | Hawthorn | 2 |
| Geoff Wilson | Hawthorn | 2 |
| Ian Ridley | Melbourne | 2 |
| Alan Rowarth | Melbourne | 2 |
| Ken Dean | North Melbourne | 2 |
| John Dugdale | North Melbourne | 2 |
| Ray Allsop | Richmond | 2 |
| Ron McDonald | Richmond | 2 |
| Col Saddington | Richmond | 2 |
| Roy Wright | Richmond | 2 |
| Ken McCormack | South Melbourne | 2 |
| Brian McGowan | South Melbourne | 2 |
| John Chick | Carlton | 1 |
| Berkeley Cox | Carlton | 1 |
| Ron ODwyer | Carlton | 1 |
| Peter Webster | Carlton | 1 |
| Ken Fraser | Essendon | 1 |
| Col Hebbard | Essendon | 1 |
| Hugh Mitchell | Essendon | 1 |
| Bob Shearman | Essendon | 1 |
| John Towner | Essendon | 1 |
| Wally Clark | Fitzroy | 1 |
| Vin Williams | Fitzroy | 1 |
| Barry Connolly | Footscray | 1 |
| Ron Porta | Footscray | 1 |
| Don Whitten | Footscray | 1 |
| Bruce Ferrari | Geelong | 1 |
| Noel Voight | Hawthorn | 1 |
| Garry English | North Melbourne | 1 |
| Dave Cuzens | Richmond | 1 |
| Tom Hafey | Richmond | 1 |
| Ted Langridge | Richmond | 1 |
| Jim Dorgan | South Melbourne | 1 |
| Ian Tampion | South Melbourne | 1 |
| Ray Barrett | St Kilda | 1 |
| Geoff Feehan | St Kilda | 1 |
| John Hayes | St Kilda | 1 |
| Allan Jeans | St Kilda | 1 |
| Bob Kupsch | St Kilda | 1 |
| Brian Walsh | St Kilda | 1 |
| Team | Votes |
|---|---|
| Collingwood | 67 |
| Essendon | 65 |
| Fitzroy | 59 |
| St Kilda | 57 |
| South Melbourne | 55 |
| Hawthorn | 55 |
| North Melbourne | 52 |
| Geelong | 52 |
| Carlton | 51 |
| Footscray | 49 |
| Melbourne | 46 |
| Richmond | 40 |