| Player | TM | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| Keith Greig | North Melbourne | 27 |
| Gary Hardeman | Melbourne | 23 |
| Kevin Bartlett | Richmond | 22 |
| Gary Dempsey | Footscray | 19 |
| Leigh Matthews | Hawthorn | 15 |
| Francis Bourke | Richmond | 15 |
| Rex Hunt | Richmond | 15 |
| Bernie Quinlan | Footscray | 14 |
| John Hendrie | Hawthorn | 13 |
| Graham Moss | Essendon | 12 |
| Harvey Merrigan | Fitzroy | 11 |
| Max Richardson | Collingwood | 10 |
| Glenn Elliott | St Kilda | 10 |
| Bohdan Jaworskyj | Hawthorn | 9 |
| Gary Crane | Carlton | 8 |
| David McKay | Carlton | 8 |
| Laurie Richards | Fitzroy | 8 |
| Ray Huppatz | Footscray | 8 |
| Malcolm Blight | North Melbourne | 8 |
| Robert McGhie | Richmond | 8 |
| Norm Goss | South Melbourne | 8 |
| Alan Noonan | Essendon | 7 |
| Geoff Pryor | Essendon | 7 |
| Garry Wilson | Fitzroy | 7 |
| Bruce Nankervis | Geelong | 7 |
| Barry Davis | North Melbourne | 7 |
| Wayne Schimmelbusch | North Melbourne | 7 |
| Royce Hart | Richmond | 7 |
| Peter Bedford | South Melbourne | 7 |
| Rodney Ashman | Carlton | 6 |
| Phil Manassa | Collingwood | 6 |
| Graeme Shephard | Collingwood | 6 |
| Warwick Irwin | Fitzroy | 6 |
| Ian Salmon | Footscray | 6 |
| Sam Newman | Geelong | 6 |
| Paul Sarah | Geelong | 6 |
| Peter Knights | Hawthorn | 6 |
| Alan Martello | Hawthorn | 6 |
| Greg Wells | Melbourne | 6 |
| Ian Thomson | South Melbourne | 6 |
| Brian Woodman | South Melbourne | 6 |
| Barry Armstrong | Carlton | 5 |
| Geoff Southby | Carlton | 5 |
| Bob Heard | Collingwood | 5 |
| Barry Price | Collingwood | 5 |
| Neville Fields | Essendon | 5 |
| Robert Neal | Geelong | 5 |
| Kelvin Matthews | Hawthorn | 5 |
| John Burns | North Melbourne | 5 |
| Barry Goodingham | North Melbourne | 5 |
| Sam Kekovich | North Melbourne | 5 |
| Laurie Fowler | Richmond | 5 |
| Paul Sproule | Richmond | 5 |
| Russell Cook | South Melbourne | 5 |
| Stewart Gull | South Melbourne | 5 |
| Alex Jesaulenko | Carlton | 4 |
| Ross Dunne | Collingwood | 4 |
| Wayne Richardson | Collingwood | 4 |
| Len Thompson | Collingwood | 4 |
| Ken Fletcher | Essendon | 4 |
| Des Tuddenham | Essendon | 4 |
| Andrew Wilson | Essendon | 4 |
| John Murphy | Fitzroy | 4 |
| Kevin OKeeffe | Fitzroy | 4 |
| Gareth Andrews | Geelong | 4 |
| Ricky Browne | Geelong | 4 |
| Kevin Higgins | Geelong | 4 |
| Kevin Heath | Hawthorn | 4 |
| Bryan Wood | Richmond | 4 |
| John Pitura | South Melbourne | 4 |
| Allan Davis | St Kilda | 4 |
| Bruce Duperouzel | St Kilda | 4 |
| Peter Jones | Carlton | 3 |
| Vin Waite | Carlton | 3 |
| Graeme Dunstan | Collingwood | 3 |
| Bill Picken | Collingwood | 3 |
| Ron Andrews | Essendon | 3 |
| Laurie Moloney | Essendon | 3 |
| Ray Smith | Essendon | 3 |
| Kevin Murray | Fitzroy | 3 |
| Dennis Collins | Footscray | 3 |
| Glenn Gingell | Footscray | 3 |
| Greg Parke | Footscray | 3 |
| Stephen Power | Footscray | 3 |
| Barry Round | Footscray | 3 |
| Laurie Sandilands | Footscray | 3 |
| John Scarlett | Geelong | 3 |
| Michael Turner | Geelong | 3 |
| Brian Douge | Hawthorn | 3 |
| Des Meagher | Hawthorn | 3 |
| Stan Alves | Melbourne | 3 |
| Frank Giampaolo | Melbourne | 3 |
| John Tilbrook | Melbourne | 3 |
| Arnold Briedis | North Melbourne | 3 |
| Barry Cable | North Melbourne | 3 |
| Dick Clay | Richmond | 3 |
| Mike Green | Richmond | 3 |
| Steve Hoffman | South Melbourne | 3 |
| Greg Lambert | South Melbourne | 3 |
| Russell Greene | St Kilda | 3 |
| Brian Mynott | St Kilda | 3 |
| Kevin Neale | St Kilda | 3 |
| Travis Payze | St Kilda | 3 |
| Rod Austin | Carlton | 2 |
| Craig Davis | Carlton | 2 |
| Phillip Pinnell | Carlton | 2 |
| Robert Dean | Collingwood | 2 |
| John Williams | Collingwood | 2 |
| Simon Madden | Essendon | 2 |
| Neville Taylor | Fitzroy | 2 |
| Adrian Gallagher | Footscray | 2 |
| Peter Welsh | Footscray | 2 |
| Geoff Ainsworth | Geelong | 2 |
| David Clark | Geelong | 2 |
| Ian Hampshire | Geelong | 2 |
| Ian Nankervis | Geelong | 2 |
| Michael Moncrieff | Hawthorn | 2 |
| Kelvin Moore | Hawthorn | 2 |
| Leon Rice | Hawthorn | 2 |
| Carl Ditterich | Melbourne | 2 |
| Robert Flower | Melbourne | 2 |
| Mal Owens | Melbourne | 2 |
| Tony Sullivan | Melbourne | 2 |
| David Dench | North Melbourne | 2 |
| Frank Gumbleton | North Melbourne | 2 |
| David Thorpe | Richmond | 2 |
| Wayne Walsh | Richmond | 2 |
| Peter Brown | South Melbourne | 2 |
| Neil Besanko | St Kilda | 2 |
| Russell Reynolds | St Kilda | 2 |
| Jeff Sarau | St Kilda | 2 |
| Stephen Theodore | St Kilda | 2 |
| David Dickson | Carlton | 1 |
| Bruce Doull | Carlton | 1 |
| Trevor Keogh | Carlton | 1 |
| Ian Robertson | Carlton | 1 |
| Brian Walsh | Carlton | 1 |
| George Bisset | Collingwood | 1 |
| Allan Holmes | Collingwood | 1 |
| Peter McKenna | Collingwood | 1 |
| Rod Oborne | Collingwood | 1 |
| Ray Shaw | Collingwood | 1 |
| Rob Newton | Essendon | 1 |
| Pat Wellington | Essendon | 1 |
| Andrew Lukas | Fitzroy | 1 |
| Ian McCulloch | Fitzroy | 1 |
| Glenn Robertson | Fitzroy | 1 |
| Ross Abbey | Footscray | 1 |
| Colin Dell | Footscray | 1 |
| Stuart Magee | Footscray | 1 |
| Alan Stoneham | Footscray | 1 |
| Jack Hawkins | Geelong | 1 |
| Michael Tuck | Hawthorn | 1 |
| Ray Biffin | Melbourne | 1 |
| John Clennett | Melbourne | 1 |
| Peter Keenan | Melbourne | 1 |
| Greg Wood | Melbourne | 1 |
| Gary Cowton | North Melbourne | 1 |
| Garry Farrant | North Melbourne | 1 |
| Mick Nolan | North Melbourne | 1 |
| Vic Aanensen | South Melbourne | 1 |
| Paul Callery | St Kilda | 1 |
| Rod Galt | St Kilda | 1 |
| Wayne Judson | St Kilda | 1 |
| George Young | St Kilda | 1 |
| Team | Votes |
|---|---|
| Richmond | 91 |
| North Melbourne | 77 |
| Footscray | 73 |
| Hawthorn | 71 |
| Collingwood | 59 |
| Essendon | 56 |
| Carlton | 53 |
| Geelong | 51 |
| South Melbourne | 50 |
| Melbourne | 50 |
| Fitzroy | 48 |
| St Kilda | 42 |