Semis - 1958
| 19-Aug-1958,Redfern | |||||||
| Balmain 15 | Newtown 4 | ||||||
| Bill Marsh | 1 | Roley Selem | 2 | ||||
| Keith Barnes | 6 | ||||||
| 23-Aug-1958,S.C.G. | |||||||
| Balmain 22 | Manly 10 | ||||||
| Frank Drake | 1 | Ray Ritchie | 1 | ||||
| Bill Bischoff | 1 | Ray Quinnell | 1 | ||||
| Keith Barnes | 8 | Ron Willey | 2 | ||||
| 30-Aug-1958,S.C.G. | |||||||
| Wests 34 | St George 10 | ||||||
| Peter Dimond | 2 | Eddie Lumsden | 1 | ||||
| Neville Charlton | 1 | Bob Bugden | 1 | ||||
| Bernie Kelly | 1 | Harry Bath | 2 | ||||
| Darcy Russell | 1 | 8 | |||||
| Bill Carson | 1 | ||||||
| 06-Sep-1958,S.C.G. | |||||||
| St George 26 | Balmain 21 | ||||||
| Norm Provan | 1 | Bill Bischoff | 1 | ||||
| Ken Kearney | 1 | Ron Clifford | 1 | ||||
| Bob Bugden | 1 | Kevin Smyth | 1 | ||||
| Eddie Lumsden | 1 | Keith Barnes | 6 | ||||
| Brian Messiter | 1 | ||||||
| Brian Clay | 1 | ||||||
| Harry Bath | 4 | ||||||
| 13-Sep-1958,S.C.G. | |||||||
| St George 20 | Wests 9 | ||||||
| Norm Provan | 2 | Darcy Russell | 1 | 3 | |||
| Eddie Lumsden | 1 | ||||||
| Bob Bugden | 1 | ||||||
| Harry Bath | 4 | ||||||