Round 5 - 1958
| 03-May-1958,Brookvale | |||||||
| Manly 45 | Souths 16 | ||||||
| Kevin Diett | 3 | Kevin Turner | 2 | ||||
| Ray Ritchie | 2 | John Cottee | 1 | ||||
| Bob Lenon | 2 | Ron Taylor | 1 | ||||
| Dennis Meaney | 1 | Bernie Purcell | 1 | ||||
| Bill Lloyd | 1 | Dale Puren | 1 | ||||
| Ron Willey | 9 | ||||||
| 03-May-1958,Leichhardt | |||||||
| Balmain 14 | Newtown 13 | ||||||
| Keith Barnes | 7 | Terry McGovern | 2 | Johnny Raper | 1 | Gordon Clifford | 2 |
| 03-May-1958,Belmore | |||||||
| Canterbury 16 | Easts 22 | ||||||
| Nick Evans | 1 | Billy McNamara | 1 | ||||
| Ken Rowlands | 1 | John Vesper | 1 | ||||
| Peter Hayes | 5 | Tony Paskins | 1 | Barry O'Connell | 1 | 5 | |
| 03-May-1958,S.C.G. | |||||||
| Wests 52 | Norths 4 | ||||||
| Keith Holman | 2 | Brian Carlson | 2 | ||||
| Harry Wells | 2 | ||||||
| Buddy Bowman | 1 | ||||||
| Kel O'Shea | 1 | ||||||
| Darcy Henry | 1 | ||||||
| Peter Dimond | 1 | ||||||
| Johnny Thompson | 1 | ||||||
| Doug Jones | 1 | ||||||
| Darcy Russell | 11 | ||||||
| 03-May-1958,Kogarah | |||||||
| St George 45 | Parramatta 11 | ||||||
| Tommy Ryan | 2 | Ray Preston | 1 | ||||
| Peter Armstrong | 1 | Bob Hansen | 4 | ||||
| Kevin Brown | 1 | ||||||
| Peter Carroll | 1 | ||||||
| Jack Fifield | 1 | ||||||
| Geoff Weekes | 1 | ||||||
| Eddie Lumsden | 1 | ||||||
| Brian Clay | 1 | ||||||
| Harry Bath | 9 | ||||||